Dedicate 5 minutes to learn more about the advantages and differences between the three largest cloud vendors.
Cloud computing has turned our way of working with IT upside down, and for most, it is not a question of cloud or not, but instead how to do it and who to choose. Joel Vest, Head of Public Cloud, takes a closer look at the benefits and differences of the three main vendors: Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, and the Google Cloud Platform.
Today, the cloud is an indispensable part of a modern IT infrastructure. These are high-performance and complex platforms that can be used as if it were your data center - dynamic, flexible, and secure. And scalable at a level that would be difficult to match for a conventional, on-premise data center.
Therefore, it makes sense many have invested massively in their cloud capacity. Today, three vendors stand out amongst the top vendors, namely Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud Platform. All three vendors offer a complete portfolio of services and a high degree of security. So, which vendor is the best one for your cloud journey?
Let's get one thing straight; all top three vendors can help many companies and organizations that desire to take advantage of the cloud. They continue to innovate and reinvent themselves which is why I suggest we take a historical look at which clientele each vendor attracts in order to make the comparison and assist in finding the right match.
My hands-on comparison of advantages and differences is based on the largest and oldest of the three cloud vendors:
Amazon Web Services
It was way back in March 2006 that Amazon launched its web services with both Simple Storage Service and Elastic Compute Cloud. The idea was to offer a kind of 'operating system for the Internet' based on Amazon's strong muscles within IT infrastructure. Thus, AWS gained a first-mover advantage, and this lead has lasted until today when AWS is the largest of the top three providers.
AWS has attracted companies and organizations that have been technically heavy and have typically developed proprietary applications. Historically, there have been many Linux-based development companies among the customers, and you can extensively tailor your infrastructure services to your requirements and needs.
Perhaps AWS has had a little less focus on hybrid solutions, where you mix public cloud and on-premise data center, but today you can build hybrid solutions with AWS as provider and platform. It's a very mature platform, and if I have to mention one challenge at AWS, it may be the sheer volume of choices that can seem overwhelming - especially if one is new to the application of cloud technology.
In 2010, Microsoft came onboard with Azure, and from the beginning, it was set out to be the most prominent choice for companies. If your company or organization is based on a Microsoft platform, then the leap to Azure is evident, and the migration itself is made easy.
It is no secret that Microsoft holds a dominating market position. In several of Microsoft's products, there is almost a 'built-in button,' so you can integrate with Azure very easily and quickly.
Azure is the 'safe bet’ because everything is so well-integrated, but make no mistake: Microsoft has long embraced both open source and Linux, and Azure is the right choice for a hybrid solution. Today's Microsoft is open and integrated, and therefore it is a solution that embraces a wide range, although development is sometimes almost faster than the documentation can keep up with.
Google Cloud Platform
Launched in 2011, Google is the youngest vendor, but has claimed a stable market position. If you want to draw a profile of Google as a vendor, you can also look at who has historically chosen GCP as a cloud vendor. It has typically been a very development-driven companies because Google is traditionally a favorite among many developers.
For example, Google has developed the Kubernetes standard, which both AWS and Azure also offer, and Google is strong in data analytics. Also, GCP can ensure close integration with Google's services in the processing of Big Data and various data sources.
If we look at the downside, the Google Cloud Platform may not offer precisely the same breadth and depth of services. Still, it is essential to emphasize that there is a plethora of options for most companies and organizations.
Comparison of AWS, Azure and GCP
Amazon Web Services:
- Dominating market position
- Extensive and mature product portfolio
- Support for larger organizations
- Less focus on hybrid solutions
- Overwhelming amount of options
- The clear runner-up
- The obvious choice for MS companies
- Solid integration with MS applications
- Great for hybrid solutions and open source
Google Cloud Platform
- A favorite among developers
- Tight integration with all Google's services
- Leader within data analysis and Big Data
- Fast response times and scaling options
- Not the same width and depth as the others
A strategic or tactic decision
Now, there have been profiled the three biggest cloud vendors by looking at the clientele and what that reveals the advantages and differences. There are basically two paths to take in the decision of a cloud vendor - strategic or tactical.
The strategic decision is usually the direct approach where, as an example, if a company is a Microsoft house and, as a part of the policy, chooses cloud with Azure. Or maybe the company is development-driven where Google is the natural choice from a management perspective.
The tactical approach means to choose only one vendor or based on a mix of several pragmatic reasons. Maybe there is a need to invest in a specific type of software or another solution that is connected to a particular cloud provider.
On the other hand, the developers prefer a specific platform where there are several providers.
Either way, there is no right or wrong in the decision-making process. Each organization is unique, and the decision needs to strengthen the company in the best possible way.
Making an informed decision
In the end, how do you decide which of the three providers is the best match for your organization? It depends on different questions:
- Are you at the beginning of the cloud journey and want an overview?
- Are you already using different cloud providers and searching for an assessment?
- Is the development process in in your company complex and requiring special tools?
- Are there areas in your company that already have Microsoft solutions?
- Do you work a lot with data analysis, Big Data, and Google's many tools?
- Have you set your mind on a hybrid solution?
- Do you apply specific tools like Kubernetes or similar?
There is no way around finding and understanding the actual requirements before deciding on a cloud vendor. Going deeper into the needs will reveal the most relevant factor; the costs. It can be a challenging job itself to compare costs when investigating the complexity and costs between the cloud vendors.
There can be both advantages and pitfalls hidden in the cloud providers' pricing. It can be quite resourceful with an independent partner who can find the most advantageous combination and solutions based on the specific business needs.
Working with IT Outsourcing my entire career from the many different perspectives constitutes my 360-degree view of all aspects of the Managed Services business: as a Service Delivery Manager (being the customer’s advocate internally and the company’s advocate at the customer); as a project manager; as a department head, responsible for tooling; as a Solution Manager on the Sales side of the business; as an Account CTO, assisting the customer on their technical direction; as a CTO, with the responsibility for the delivery of the complete service stack to our customers and as Head of Public Cloud. As a person, I’m excited by technology, but even more interested in the new possibility it offers our customers. One of the amazing opportunities offered by working across multiple customers, is the ability to gain insights into so many businesses and to understand the various priorities that drive them. The possibilities offered by the amazing advances within public cloud only accelerates the opportunities that we can bring to our customers. But with opportunity comes challenges, and that is where we can assist with our expertise within architecture and managed services.
Find me on